End Times Prophetic, Prophecy, Visions, Dreams, Revelation, Christian Blog

Christian prophecy for the church and for the nations from a servant of God called to speak God’s word

The Roman Catholic Charismatic Movement – More Christian or Less?

As many of you know, I was brought up a Roman Catholic, and am from a very long line of Roman Catholics dating back many centuries. I was led out of Roman Catholicism just after I was gloriously saved when I heard the TRUE life-giving life-changing gospel for the very first time. [Yes. for the first  time, despite all my years at Roman Catholic school, going through first Holy Communion, the obligatory mass attendance, and the confessions to a priest behind a screen in a wooden booth, the eating of fish only on Fridays, the religious medals and statues scattered all around the house and even a visit to see the pope ....etc] 

The true gospel was as chalk and cheese to everything I have been taught. [Chalk and cheese means 'Two things that are might possibly be confused but which are in fact very different.'] It was very hard for me to understand at first because it was so very different. Sadly, my family still cannot grasp its simplicity and freedom because it is alien to everything they have been indoctrinated with – and they refuse to believe that a church can be so off for hundreds of years. You see Catholics know it is another Jesus they worship – why can’t protestants see it?

I have written a number of times about some of my experiences, these comments are scattered all around the site – but I just wanted to try and get all the comments on the Catholic Charismatic movement into one single thread for greater accessibility. Particularly as a major lie going around in these days [spread by C Peter Wagner and many others] is that ”spirit-filled” Catholics within the Catholic Charismatic Movement are not like other Roman Catholics, and are more biblical etc. However, as I have previously noted, if anything the Catholic Charismatics are more  idolatrous, and not less so.

My own experience with Catholic Charismatics is they as readily worshipped Mary as they spoke in tongues. I found them far more fervent and idolatrous and superstitious, not less so. They are more loving of the rosary, religious pictures and icons and statues, not less so. They are more aware of the saints to pray to, not less so.  They still partake of the same antichrist and gospel denying Mass while they praised Mary in tongues and love it ever more.  Needless, to say, one wonders what spirits they were dabbling in.

They had a foreign spirit on them, and they were just as ignorant, alien and opposed to real Christianity as the traditional wing of the church. Despite the claims to the contrary that people in the Catholic Charismatic fringe are finding ‘Christ ‘and are different to the old school pre Vatican II, I found the charismatic ’spirit filled’ meetings more blasphemous and more idolatrous than in the traditional wing of the church, as they were far more zealously blasphemous! They were no more enlightened by the Charismatic spirit they had received, rather they were more blinded by it! They still loved candles, grottos, medals, rosary beads, shrines and idols. They prayed also to the Saints and the dead. They still felt need of a priest to confess to and partook of Mass with the same superstitious mindset. They still crossed themselves etc. Their gospel was still one of works and they had no more hope of salvation. They still believed in purgatory. They were still superstitious – even more so. They still idolised the pope. They still blasphemed against God and practiced spiritual whoredom. The leader of these meetings said that when Jesus returned he would give all the credit to Mary. So it was not, and cannot have been, the Spirit of Truth that led them.

What does this say about some Charismatic experiences and Charismatic spirits? – it is they do not belong to truth. Another insight is this – when I came into a meeting as a visitor, they welcomed me, especially when they heard that I was brought up a ‘good’ RC. However far from being delighted that I had since been saved after responding to the true gospel, and rejoicing that I had found Jesus and my life had turned around, they were only interested in me coming back to Rome as they saw me as a backslider and not a convert or disciple of Jesus. That was their version of conversion – conversion to Rome! I refused to take mass with them – and went away much grieved in my spirit.

The Catholics don’t compromise in the ecumenical movement, it’s everyone else (eg the protestants) who compromise – who are supposed to put aside essential major doctrinal differences and agree it’s OK to call Catholics Christians now, as the twisted Catholic gospel is correct if Catholics are now Christians as they must be if the differences millions have died defending are no longer important! For when you say, yes they’re Christians, we all agree, you agree with what the Roman church teaches or do not think it is important. So its Ok to worship Mary, blaspheme against God, kiss idols, pray to Saints, deny the work of the cross, pay indulgances, accept papal infallibility and all its corruptions, attribute names to the pope that only God Himself owns and should be called, deny the gospel of grace, partake in the heretical and blasphemous and gospel denying mass, keep the word of God from the common man, as well as have such wealth stolen by corruption and evil etc etc – this is all now suddenly Christian and not antichrist?

Let’s all come back to ‘mother church’. I don’t think so. Over my, I mean, millions of others’ dead bodies. Have you read the description of the whore in Revelation who is sat on seven hills (as Rome is). Dripping with wealth, holding a gold cup dripping with the blood of martyrs, and dressed in scarlet and purple, and crowned with blasphemous names that has world leaders eating out of her pockets and vice versa. Ring any bells yet? Yet these guys are ‘Christian’? Yeah, right.  I’m an EX Roman Catholic who even went to see Pope John Paul II. Note the EX. I’m an EX for a reason, if the RC church taught the true gospel I’d still be Catholic. I know the true Christian gospel and the Catholic one is just not compatible and is chalk and cheese – even among Catholic charismatics who are just heretics who speak in other tongues. Mormons speak in other tongues, shall we embrace them too and call them Christians? ROMAN CATHOLICS ARE NOT CHRISTIANS. Though some (like me) get genuinely saved in spite of the church, they are soon led out of it by God. Besides which, the fact that a minority within an institution may or may not be saved, does not make the RC dogma or the church valid

Of course the differences between Roman Catholicism and the Bible are immense and important and millions have been martyred because of it. They reject the paganism and idolatry and heresy of Rome and rightly so. I’m not knocking the millions of Catholics bound in ignorance – they know no better, I was one once too (but I was not a Christian) – BUT the institution itself stinks and is spiritually adulterous and repellent and an ENEMY of the true gospel. Remember it is not flesh and blood we fight, I do not fight Catholic individuals themselves, I love them and weep for them, but it is against the spiritual powers and every vain thing that sets itself up in the high places in opposition against Christ…that is RC dogma and ‘Rome’ that is to be fought.

***

Some other associated threads on Catholicism -

http://endtimespropheticwords.wordpress.com/2008/05/29/todd-bentley-discipled-in-prophetic-by-a-roman-catholic-charismatic/

http://endtimespropheticwords.wordpress.com/2007/11/05/the-smoke-of-a-thousand-villages/

http://endtimespropheticwords.wordpress.com/2008/09/09/mother-teresa-of-calcuttas-blasphemy/

http://endtimespropheticwords.wordpress.com/2008/09/29/veneration-of-holy-relics-and-religious-icons/

September 29, 2008 - Posted by endtimespropheticwords | C Peter Wagner, Catholic Charismatic, False Prophets and Teachers, Fresh Fire ministries, Interfaith and Ecumenical, John Michael Talbot, One World Religion, Peter Wagner, Prophecy, Roman Catholicism, Todd Bentley, signs and wonders | , , , | 44 Comments

44 Comments »

  1. Vic said [comment moved by admin]

    I decided to check out the ministry of Steve Strader leading the Ignite Church where this current move began after friends fro the UK had been attending morning meetings there as well as the evening with Todd Bentley.
    Here is part of a missions report from his site:

    ‘Highlight of the day was a 2:30 pm meeting with the Catholic Charismatic Youth Alive! What a story!

    In 1993 a visiting Catholic priest came to the RODNEY HOWARD-BROWNE revival. He was touched by God. He invited Gil Howard-Browne to his youth rally’s a few years later. Today I came and we had a HOLY GHOST BLOW OUT! Over 400 young people were on the floor in the Holy Spirit. Dozens came forward because they were away from God. Several parents who were looking in on the meeting were also saved! The Glory fell during praise & worship. You have NEVER ever heard anything like it! These kids are very sensitive to the Holy Spirit. They had a mirror ball spinning on the ceiling of the stage for youthful atmosphere. They had a statue of Mary with burning candles next to my pulpit.

    So when I preached on the Power of the Holy Spirit falling in Acts 2, I reminded them that the Blessed Virgin was in attendance in the upper room and she spoke in tongues! They all cheered! Wed AM back at the Bible School. … Wed PM another youth rally, this time in Talisae. About 1200 youth in an open side gym. Awesome dramas and dance and mime. The best I’ve seen in the Philippines! Over 80% responded to the altar call. I made it hard. I told them that if they came forward they would have to leave their friends, music, movies. anything that was impure. I explained it several times. Then they flooded the altar! It was awesome! The team moved in and laid hands on every one of them. Then the band kicked into gear and we danced the night away! There ain’t no party like a Holy ghost party!’
    http://www.stephenstrader.com/phillipines.htm

    Strader does not appear to consider idol worship and mystical Catholic practices ‘impure’. If they had been challanged to repent from these I wonder how many would have stayed on to enjoy the party!
    Daniel prophesied that the antichrist would change God’s laws and seasons 7:25. Catholicism has changed the 10 Commandments, removing no. 2 about graven images/idolatry and splitting a later one into two. God’s prophetic calander of rememption, which has much to teach us about what is to come, is replaced by ‘christianized’ pagan events.

    Interestingly, I like Todd, attended a Monday night ecumenical charismatic prayer group as an early believer as there seemed some action compared to dry churches around.
    There was certainly worship and some good visiting speakers but the catholics kept there erroneous beliefs out of sight. Alarm bells rang for me when I was invited to share a few words about returning to Spain on a short term mission trip. I expained that there were less then 40,000 born again believers there, less that Jehovah’s witnesses. I was naive I guess, but there was an almighty stir among the catholics after this who obviously considerd the greater population of Spain as ‘born again’ who attend seriously idolatrous churches and festivals.

    There are so many evangelical, charismatic and Pentacostal leaders and movements, who would have been considered sound just a few years ago, that are opening up to the Church of Rome that we cannot rule anything out. Things are moving FAST.
    I read a while ago a warning that many would begin speaking about the birth of ‘the Christ’ through the overshadowing of the spirit on Mary (figuratively the Church). Lo and behold, Todd referred to Luke1:35, a few night back. One of the few actual bible verses I have seen him read out.
    John Crowder was in town recently with some from Lakeland for a ‘Sloshfest’ conference. He was encouraging christians to download antything going – levitation, bilocation,etc. and there were even lightheated reference to stigmata. One young man in the prayer line even daid he would be willing to pierce himself for the glory (Catholics even get crucified in dome parts of the world to express devotion)I could not believe that many who did not challange this had been in the same interdenominational mission organistaion as my wife and I.
    WAKE UP AND STAY ALERT. VERY SOBERING AND NOT A TIME FOR A DRUNKEN STUPOUR.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  2. David W said [comment moved by admin]

    just gogggled knights of malta. had never heard of it. what a sinister bunch and one can see how they could very easily be the back door.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  3. Tom said [comment moved by admin]

    “Catholics do not worship Mary or the saints. we ask them to pray for us in the same way that any of you would ask a friend or family member to pray for you.”

    First, I would have to say calling on someone who isn’t here for anything is tantamount to prayer. You’re asking someone else to pray for you when you can do your own praying – why would you do that? Why hold God at arm’s length? When Jesus demonstrated “The Lord’s Prayer,” as it’s come to be known, he did pray to Abraham, David, or Moses & ask them to pray, he prayed directly to the Father, which is what he TOLD us to do.

    Further, there’s no scriptural support to pray to or through them. 1 Timothy 2 says “For there is one God, and one mediator also between God and men, the man Christ Jesus.”

    Take a look at this link, which is a web site of and by the Catholic church:
    http://www.catholic.org/clife/prayers/prayer.php?s=41

    It clearly shows MANY prayers actually TO these so-called saints, such as “A prayer to Saint Therese De Lisieux for Guidance,” or “Unfailing Prayer to St. Anthony,” which says: “O Holy St. Anthony, gentlest of Saints, your love for God and Charity for His creatures, made you worthy, when on earth, to possess miraculous powers. Encouraged by this thought, I implore you to obtain for me (request).”

    What’s clear is the Catholic Church not only condones worship of and prayer to saints, but it encourages it. I’ll have to do some more research to see if there are specific commands from some Pope or other through history requiring it.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  4. DoubleGrace said [comment moved by admin]

    I was raised Catholic to and come from several generations of Catholics(could explain all of the dreams I’ve had of being in a Catholic church but something was always wrong, like a black widow spider perched on my eye.) Anyway, after my husband and I got saved, we received intense opposition from my family (his mother’s family was Catholic but she had abandoned it to marry his Methodist father, so she didn’t mind.) We also befriended a sweet Catholic woman at one point(who was also a hair stylist,that’s how we met her). We had been recently spirit filled and she invited us to a “Charismatic Catholic” meeting. Soon they were all “speaking in tongues” to Mary. We never went back.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  5. OhhowILOVEJESUS said [comment moved by admin]

    I remember years ago when I was pentecostlized and had dabbled in catholicism there were 2 guest speakers that had been excommunicated from the catholic church for becoming catholic charismatics. They were ex Franciscan nuns, so yes there is a charismatic movement in the cathloic church. It is more excepted now then it was years ago probably because attendence is dropping majorly, so some churches combine. They have followed the pentecostle and still some catholic doctrine. Just like many other denomations, they branch out.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  6. BB said [comment moved by admin]

    I’ve attended John Michael Talbot concerts and he likes to say that the Catholic Charismatic movement is bigger than Pentecostalism! That there are over 10 million charismatics in the Catholic Church. By saying this he hopes to draw charismatics back into the mother church.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  7. Redeemed Hippie said [comment moved by admin]

    I know of some wonderful catholic people. Yet they have added and taken from the Word of God just like any other cult beliefs. So therefore, if anyone tells them differently are we their enemy for telling them the truth? you either love truth or you hate it. Simple as that.

    I remember a Benny hinn crusade I went to. He showed a movie on mother Teresa for the whole audience to see. It did not set right with me then and still does not set right

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  8. Bull said [comment moved by admin]

    I have met a few very fine Christians who attend catholic churches.

    I have met others who have only a very superficial understanding of catholic teaching (as opposed to Christian teaching).

    The difference is very stark. The majority of Catholics, I believe, are still kept in spiritual darkness through either bad teaching, no teaching or even keeping the whole thing in Latin (for the ‘old’ catholics)

    However, I once heard of David Pawson’s church that one day were told to start saving up money in a seperate account from the main church finances. A good baptist church, the managed to save up quite a bit of money. Sometime later a terrible storm struck and the roof of the local catholic church was badly damaged. The Holy Spirit told them to give the money they had saved (good Baptist money!) to the catholic priest (and these were ‘old’ catholics … the Latins!). So they did. The Priest was overwhelmed (they didn’t have access to the Vatican coffers since they weren’t in communion with them since Vatican II) and as a result he started sending his congregants (I think he went too) to Davids church, which was known for his systematic Bible teaching.

    It reminds me of a story from World War 2 in North Africa. A British land rover suddenly found itself surrounded by Italian troops. They radioed back to HQ “We’re surrounded by prisoners!”

    Rommel, who was dispatched to take control of the situation came to the conclusion that Italian troops were pretty good, they were just poorly led.

    Catholics are the same … they could be really good christians … they have been poorly led, and badly taught.

    But before protestants think they have made it … well, just look at the state of the Anglican Church. How many of them are only nominal christians (including the professional clergy!). Look at the Methodists, the Lutherans, the independents, the Vineyards, the Hillsongs, the rest of them …

    How many people in the church we attend every Sunday are truly born-again?

    How many people in Christian ministry are truly Born-Again?

    I tell you the truth … some Catholics are truly born-again. Some Anglicans are. Some Methodists. Some independent. Some Hillsong. Some Christian City Church too.

    But not all.

    I’m sorry if this is taken the wrong way, but while it is easy to slam Catholic teaching, the majority of people attending no nothing else. They are poorly led.

    Like the rest of us. If we are honest with ourselves, we would simply admit that the leaders we know in church do not live up to our expectations. In fact they fall far below them.

    Or am I speaking for myself?

    I am not saying Miriam is wrong about catholicism here. I am saying the tar brush needs to extend to all churches.

    How many of us are deeply dissatisfied with our churches?

    There is a poster for the Alpha Course in the church window.

    “Is This it?” meaning is this all the life I can expect or something.

    I find it to be a very ironic question every Sunday Morning.

    Is this all church can be? Is this it?

    Shalom.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  9. I said [comment moved by admin]

    Bull:

    Because I say Roman Catholicism is from the pits of hell, it does not mean I condone all modern day Christianity as practiced in ‘protestant’ churches. You are well aware that this blog draws attention to many of the faults within ‘protestantism’.

    However my point to Russell and my point to you too is that someone can not be a good Catholic Christian. It is an impossibility as a ‘good Catholic’ and a ‘Christian’ are polar opposites of each other.

    >> Catholics are the same … they could be really good christians

    They cannot be, though, that’s the thing. It is totally impossible.

    They can be ‘good’ people, and ‘good’ religious practicioners just as Mormons or JWs or New Agers or any religion can be ‘good’ people [though Jesus said no man is good]. Many RC people put protestantism to shame as they do tend to do a lot more social work. They can be very kind people indeed. But a kind and good person is not by default a Christian. Nor is a religious person, even with someone who has the pretext their religion is based on the Bible when it is patently not.

    They can call themselves Christian but that does not make them Christian.

    You mention an unusual story from David Pawson, but that in no way makes your point.

    RC folk are in darkness. It is right they do have poor leadership extending from the common clergy right up to the Pope. But one cannot just blame the clergy as it is the essentials of the doctrine and the practices that is antichrist itself. It is not the gospel preached. Despite my baptism into the church, my RC education, my mass attendance and First Holy Communion and all the confessions etc and even my visit to see the pope, I never heard the gospel ever. I never knew why Jesus really died. Such a fundamental though I could tell you about the saints and the popes and even more about Peter, the only bit of the Bible I was taught at school (distorted)

    Can a RC person be genuinely saved in spite of the doctrine and in spite of the darkness? Yes, I was (by being reached by protestants). Even though I knew essentially nothing about the Bible when I was born again, except the simple gospel message (and note that nobody told me that the RC faith was wrong) – I very soon realised that it was chalk and cheese with the true gospel and totally incompatible. Even the gospel message was hard to understand because of my indoctrination up to that point. Likewise my RC family cannot grasp the simplicity and freedom of the true gospel message or concieve how their religion can be so wrong.

    When a Roman Catholic becomes born again they have to make a choice, as they begin to see their old faith is as chalk and cheese to their new faith. Whether they do a Martin Luther or not, the Holy Spirit leads them out of the fake church, whatever their ignorance about either faith. The ritual of mass itself, an essential for a Catholic, is antichrist and continually denies the cross. That is just ONE thing out of literally dozens of things one has to leave behind.

    As for the Catholic Charismatics, despite their claims, they are in just as much darkness, if not more so as they are more passionate. A few years after I was saved I went to a meeting where they praised Mary in tongues, took mass, still felt equal need of the priests and their idols (if not more so), and said when Jesus came back all the glory would go to Mary…. so much for being renewed….

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  10. I said [comment moved by admin]

    I know for someone who has not been there it is hard to grasp. And that is not me being patronising, as when I speak to ‘born’ protestants many think the RC faith is just another denomination like the baptists. They do not know what is really taught or practicised.

    As to strong language (apart from remembering the apostle John’s comments about the whore riding the beast), imagine if someone was saying Satanism or something really obvious you knew was really vile was ‘Christian’. How would you respond and what words would you use in refuting that?!

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  11. Bull said [comment moved by admin]

    You said “As for the Catholic Charismatics, despite their claims, they are in just as much darkness, if not more so as they are more passionate. A few years after I was saved I went to a meeting where they praised Mary in tongues, took mass, still felt equal need of the priests and their idols (if not more so), and said when Jesus came back all the glory would go to Mary…. so much for being renewed….”

    hmm.

    I bow to your greater knowledge. The point I was making with the story though is that once a psychological barrier is broken between ‘catholics’ and bible-believing, full immersion baptism, born-again believers, the ‘catholics’ end up with a deep hunger for the word of God and end up discovering the truth. You see, the whole reason for keeping services in Latin and maintaining a professional priesthood is to maintain control. But once you have sincere believers who then study the word for themselves, they will end up becoming born-again.

    They end up believing that they have entered a royal priesthood and the laity is then abolished.

    I don’t know the end result of that collaboration between the Baptist and Latin Church. Some within that church would no doubt have dug their heels in and remained strict adherents to pre-Vatican II practices. Others would have become born-again. I hope that the priest became born-again.

    I didn’t disagree with you that the catholic clergy, whether they know this or not, are keeping their people in the dark. I agree with you that they need salvation just as much as I do, they need the truth just as much as I do and they need to have a direct relationship with Abba Father just as much as I do.

    How do we reach out to them?

    How can we draw them into just reading the Bible for themselves? I am convinced that all that is needed is some solid teaching and Sincere catholics will be able to take that leap of faith. As time goes by they will start to ask the right questions of their leaders and come to their own conclusions. I agree with you that it is pretty impossible for someone to come to faith and remain in the catholic church … however, the point I made of lack of perfection of doctrine in every church is a valid one even though the point you made about the visible catholic faith being one of darkness is basically true. I would like to point out though that there are people within that church and in all churches who are searching and find what they are searching for. For Luther, it meant starting the protestant reformation.

    I am only trying to say that the Lord is drawing men and women to Himself from everywhere.

    “My house shall be FULL!”

    I would also like to point out that even though the real church in the UK is growing, Islam is growing much faster. But when the outlook is bad, try the UP-look!

    Even so, Come Lord Jesus!!!

    Shalom

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  12. I said [comment moved by admin]

    Bull:

    There is a big difference of approaches (usually) between talking to a protestant Christian or congregation about what Roman Catholicism really is, in order to warn them and beware of being taken in by it, and between reaching an individual Roman Catholic lost in darkness. It is possibly these two points you have confused as both approaches would be entirely different.

    When a flock reaches out across these so-called psychological barriers, flock to flock, normally what results is ecumenicism and meeting at the lowest common denominator – with nothing changing but the protestants who become more Catholic. I have seen it way too many times. What happened with David Pawson sound very rare indeed and is not quite the same thing.

    However, when the flock reaches out one on one, it is different. One of the people groups I have been most succesful with (because of the grace and gifts of God alone) when evangelising them are Roman Catholics. Whereas the ‘born protestants’ on the missions teams would hear the Catholic we met say ‘I believe in Jesus as my Lord’ and ‘I believe Jesus died for me’ or other such verbage, and be fobbed off by them going away smiling thinking they met a saved believer, I would know what they really meant by these terms – and carry on talking and in many cases lead them out of darkness to become really born again and saved. The change in these people was astounding – one woman in particular in the shadow of Celtic Park.

    I never evangelised individual Roman Catholics – even priests – with strong language or ‘you believe in the whore of Babylon’ screams and Bible thumping like some may imagine. I did or do not look like a ranting Orange man. I reached them respectfully with the gospel as I would almost anyone. In the same way, I would rarely if ever evangelise a Mormon by talking about Joseph Smith’s paedophilia.

    BUT THERE IS A WHOLE ANOTHER DIFFERENCE between talking to SAVED BELIEVERS of a religious cult’s dangers (many of whom who should know better already) and evangelising those lost in that cult who know no better.

    By the way, all my family are lost in Romanist darkness and have been for many generations. When I got saved, I was no longer a believer to them, even though I was totally transformed. Likewise, priests and nuns tried to reach out to me to come back into the fold as they feared for my ’salvation’ because I had become born again – they soon gave up. They truly would have rathered me be in total darkness with lip confession only, going through the rites, than be a redeemed Bible believer and that is the truth.

    The Catholic Charismatics I met some years later were no better – indeed worse, as they were more heretically passionate. They too considered me lost and not a true sister, though they rejoiced when they heard I had once been a Roman Catholic of good Irish stock – (Once a Catholic, always a Catholic as the saying goes) – and saw my way of salvation as having an updated confession with the priests and getting into mass again. Until then, I was lost.

    You see Roman Catholics really know this – that protestants are not believers according to them and need to come back to Mother Church! It is the protestants that are foolish enough to believe that ecumenical interfaith church events is really a genuine effort to meet across denominational barriers, or the Catholic spin we are all of one flock really. It ain’t, it is Catholic PR!

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  13. Greg said [comment moved by admin]

    Hi all.

    I was born into catholicism ( no choice)made my holy communion at seven confirmation at eight and was an alterboy also.These sacraments as they are called are the backbone of indoctrinating children into catholicism.

    let me explain what they mean. Holy Communion: It is believed that at age seven a child comes to the age of understanding of sin and therefore is old enough to receive their first holy communion. This means that they are receiving Jesus body and blood into themselves. This is a lie.

    Confirmation: This is when at age twelve you attend a ceremony officiated over by a bishop as an ordinary priest will not do. He lays hands on you and the holy spirit comes upon you to confirm your faith. This is a lie.

    In both the practices above you children are being told they are communing with God when nothing of the sort is happening.Now I ask anybody who would argue with me. If a top ranking clergyman two positions away from the pope cannot discern this nor can the pope himself because he sanctions it, then what is happening here.

    Let me run another one by you who would argue. In the beattitudes we are told blessed are the pure in heart for they shall see God. In R.C doctrine this is called the beatific vision and only those who reach sainthood will see the face of God. Hence cannonisation, sainthood. Now in the bible I read saints are sinners, bad people who believed they were bad and saw their need for a saviour.

    when I came to repent believe in Jesus as the son of God seventeen years ago I had been reading just prior to this a Douay version of the R.C bible and read the Doctrines in the back.

    On the night that God my father in heaven revealed to me who Jesus was, the most awesome night of my life, on that same night I saw CLEARLY that the R.C church as in the clergy not the sheep, was an utter and outright blasphemy against God and nothing less. It is a false Christianty that has ABSOLUTELY nothing!! to do with God. It is a lie from the enemy. If anyone ANYONE!! thinks that they can be born again and remain in the R.C church then they are either completely ignorant of what it teaches or they are not truly born again. The Lord will join his children together not leave them in ignorance.

    Greg.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  14. Cathy said [comment moved by admin]

    From what I’ve heard him say on tape, David Wilkerson does not have understanding regarding the fact that Roman Catholics are not Christians. He also does not seem to understand that if you claim to be born again you cannot stay in the Catholic Church. This includes Catholic charismatics. My husband and I were in the Catholic charismatic renewal movement and they are (we were) heavily into “Mary” and “Marian Apparitions.” Also they are into being “slain in the spirit” and rosaries turning to gold etc. This is what we came out of. To say you can get saved and stay there is like saying a Muslim can stay in a Mosque after he comes to Christ. Wilkerson was also involved in Katherine Kuhlman’s ministry, whose ministry was questionable. She had Roman Catholic priests on the platform with her when she ministered. I don’t dislike David Wilkerson, we just can’t make an idol out of him and receive his teachings without questioning them. There is that danger because he is immensely popular and he’s not wild. False teachings come in many forms. I speak this as a former Roman Catholic who loves the Body of Christ and loves Roman Catholics, wanting to see them Roman Catholics saved.

    Cathy

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  15. I said [comment moved by admin]

    Cathy:

    I would love to hear more from you re Catholic Charisma. I too was once a Roman Catholic and agree that to stay there is like saying a Muslim can stay in a Mosque after he comes to Christ – {but also saying that have you heard this is one of the controversial things YWAM have been doing?]

    David Wilkerson has some really great stuff. And other stuff that misses the mark. Every teacher needs tested and weighed.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  16. Cathy said [comment moved by admin]

    Hi Miriam,

    The doctrine of Roman Catholic charismatics is the same as the doctrine of traditional Roman Catholicism. In fact Catholic doctrine is followed with a greater zeal and intensity within the Catholic charismatic renewal movement. I also believe the Catholic charismatic movement is more dangerous than traditional Catholicism because there is a greater focus on the supernatural, and there is much exuberance and enthusiasm, which can be a lure for the unsuspecting. It was for me.

    The problem is that central to Catholic charismatic gatherings, as in all Catholic gatherings, is the Mass. The Jesus of the eucharist (the communion bread) is worshiped. Mary is also very central. At every Catholic charismatic service I have ever attended, and my husband and I were part of that group for about 3 years, the rosary was said repeatedly throughout the entire service. These “services” would usually last for several hours, and the church was always “standing room only” packed.

    The fruit . . . my husband wanted to buy a huge statue of Mary so that he could have a shrine in our attic! We also thought about making a pilgrimage to Medjugorje where “Mary” was supposedly “appearing.” Praise God that we never did either. We became born again and realized that we had been under great deception. We tried to witness to some who were still within the “renewal” but our witness was not received.

    Hope this helped. Let me know if you want to know anything else.

    Cathy

    I have been a Christian for over 20 years and have been very involved in the organized church in the past. Much to my dismay, and my husband’s dismay, our testimony was not received by most in church leadership.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  17. Cathy said [comment moved by admin]

    Left out one thing . . . for a season we became “evangelists for Mary.” Can you imagine that? We handed out literature and showed videos of the messages coming forth from the Marian apparitions. We were so deceived.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  18. I said [comment moved by admin]

    I know what you mean as as an ex Catholic myself, most ‘protestants’ refuse to see that Catholicism is that bad. Even when you tell them how bad it is, they make out you are a bigot for insisting it is not Christian. But they reject and demonise far smaller things as dreadful indeed that do even make up 1% of the badness of RC teachings.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  19. cathy said [comment moved by admin]

    You can read my testimony here . . .

    http://giannina.wordpress.com/2007/09/24/my-testimony/

    Cathy

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  20. This is Part One of Cathy’s testimony which I am pasting here for others to read -

    “Romans 1:16 For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek.

    It began in the 1980’s. We lived across the street from a Catholic Church and one evening I happened to be looking out my front door. I saw a crowd of people gathering and it was apparent that some of them were ill. Something unusual was going on and it piqued my interest. I found out later that the people were there for a “charismatic healing Mass.” I had never heard of such a thing. My teenage son had asthma so I was eager to know what the healing Mass was all about. Through further inquiry we found out that there was a Catholic priest who traveled from parish to parish conducting healing Masses. The next time he came to our church we went to the Mass. This was the beginning of our journey through the Catholic Charismatic Renewal.

    As a result of our involvement in the renewal, my husband and I became:

    1. Devoted to the Mass. (The Mass continues the Sacrifice of the Cross. Each time the Mass is offered, the Sacrifice of Christ is repeated. The New Saint Joseph Baltimore Catechism, pages 5, 7, 162, 168, 171, 182, 254, Official Revised Edition, No. 2, Catholic Book Publishing Co., NY)

    2. Devoted to worship of the “host”. The “host” is the communion bread. The priest said the bread was Jesus.

    3. Devoted to Mary. The renewal promoted the rosary, and the global apparitions of “Mary”, especially the most recent ones in Medjugorje, Bosnia. These apparitions were bringing forth “messages” for the world to hear. We began to proclaim these “messages” to others, not realizing that they contradicted the bible and teachings of Jesus. We became “evangelists for Mary.”

    We did these things because we did not know the scriptures.

    Hebrews 10:12 “But this man, after he had offered one sacrifice for sins for ever, sat down on the right hand of God;”

    Romans 1:25 “Who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshiped and served the creature more than the Creator, who is blessed for ever. Amen.”

    1 Timothy 2:5 “For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus;”

    One day I asked God if I was doing anything wrong. I wanted to do what was right in God’s eyes and was willing to turn away from whatever he showed me to be sin. That prayer was answered through a series of events. True believers witnessed to me, clearly showing me Rome’s errors. I was encouraged to seek truth by reading the bible, which I did. As I read the bible and prayed for understanding, it was as if a light bulb went on in my head. I understood, for the first time, my sinful condition and my need for forgiveness. I understood that Jesus alone was my Savior, and the Savior of the whole world. I realized that receiving the “sacraments” could not save anyone. I learned from scripture that the “sacrifice of the Mass”, worship of the “communion bread”, and praying to “Mary” (or any dead person) were heretical and idolatrous teachings, and would certainly damn my soul to hell.

    I realized that the “Mary” which was appearing to people around the world was not the real Mary, but a demonic counterfeit spirit. I knew the “messages” this “spirit” was proclaiming clearly contradicted the word of God, and the teachings of Jesus Christ. I prayed that if God would continue to give me understanding concerning the truth of his word, I would follow him wherever that truth would lead me. I had been deceived by false teaching. I thought I was headed for heaven when in reality I was headed for hell, and didn’t even know it. I thought I knew Christ, but I didn’t.

    After I was born again and knew the truth, I repented of my involvement in the Roman Catholic Church and it’s charismatic renewal. I could not stay there, and at the same time be obedient to Jesus Christ and his word.

    As I sought truth, I learned a biblical principle in 2 Kings 17:33,34. That principle is that the true God cannot be worshiped in our own way, nor in an idolatrous way. If that’s what we’re doing, we are not worshiping the true God at all. It’s mixture, and is nothing more than a mongrel religion.

    2 Kings 17:33, 34 “They feared the LORD, and served their own gods, after the manner of the nations whom they carried away from thence. Unto this day they do after the former manners: they fear not the LORD, neither do they after their statutes, or after their ordinances, or after the law and commandment which the LORD commanded the children of Jacob, whom he named Israel;”

    My life has never been the same since I was born again, born of the Holy Spirit. It’s not that my life is free from trouble, but there is a constant deep peace and joy that can only come from God. The Holy Spirit, the Spirit of Christ, is called the Comforter, Helper, Teacher, and Spirit of Truth. I often want to tell people that all they could ever want, all the peace, joy, love and comfort they could ever dream of, can found in the real Lord Jesus Christ.

    Isaiah 55:6-7 “Seek ye the LORD while he may be found, call ye upon him while he is near: Let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts: and let him return unto the LORD, and he will have mercy upon him; and to our God, for he will abundantly pardon.”

    Psalms 50:15 “And call upon me in the day of trouble: I will deliver thee, and thou shalt glorify me.”

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 29, 2008

  21. I’ve only known 3 Catholic Charismatics in my life, 2 priests and one nun. Two of them have spoken at Aglow meetings, and there was nothing amiss there. There were actually a few deliverances.

    Have also gone to a Catholic Charismatic meeting or two at their parish/home turf, and there was no Mary stuff going on, other than someone in the group who, after the meeting ended, hung out by the “host” for the adoration thingy they do, but this was not suggested in any way by leadership.

    Are there saved Catholics? IMHO, absolutely. There are even saved Jehovah’s Witnesses, but very few.

    Comment by Kathy | September 29, 2008

  22. Hey, I’ve got a question. Maybe someone can help me with it. Did the idea that dead people go straight to heaven or hell come from the Catholic church? I’ve never understood this theory. Because then who gets resurrected if all the souls are already off some place receiving their appropriate dues? And what need would there be for a judgment day as pictured in Rev. 22? I’m serious about this question although I may sound tongue in cheek.

    Comment by karina | September 29, 2008

  23. Thank You for this excellent post, and for standing for the gospel of Jesus Christ. I also was a former Roman Catholic, until I came to know Jesus Christ in 1989. The Catholic Charismatic movement is filled with the same doctrines that are found within the traditional Roman Catholic Church. That includes the Catholic Mass, Transubstantiation,the worship of Mary, confession and many other such doctrines. Pope John Paul II commended Poland to the care of Mary (not Jesus) right before he died. When a person speaks about these things, they are often accused of being unloving or perhaps a “Catholic basher” but nothing could be further from the truth. The Spirit of God within me compels me to preach the word of God to those that are lost, and nothing will ever stop that. I encourage others to speak up and testify for Jesus Christ, if you have been delivered from the snare of Roman Catholicism. You can read my testimony and other related articles on my blog at http://www.soulrefuge.wordpress.com and once again, I thank you for loving the Roman Catholic people enough to share the truth with them. Bill White

    Comment by Bill White | September 29, 2008

  24. The main thing that we must remember is that a false Gospel will damn your soul. This is a most serious issue that we dealing with here. The Roman Catholic Gospel is not the same Gospel that is found in the scriptures. The apostle Paul said this:

    But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed. As we said before, so say I now again, If any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed. (Galatians 1:8-9)

    When the Spirit of God opened my eyes, and delivered me from the darkness of Rome, I left that church in a very short time. The scriptures made it ever so clear to me that Jesus Christ was the only mediator that I needed, and that I myself, was now part of the priesthood of believers. (1 Peter 2:9-10) We must never forget the precious reformers who have gone before us, and who have gone to the flames, so that everyday people like you and me are able to have a Bible in our hands today. Thank You Lord Jesus for that. Here is a direct link to my testimony. http://soulrefuge.wordpress.com/2007/07/27/my-testimony-from-darkness-to-light-2/ Be Blessed in the Lord, Bill White

    Comment by soulrefuge | September 29, 2008

  25. Miriam, thanks for this article. Since I’m an American, I don’t grasp the meaning of the reference of ‘chalk and cheese’. It’s not a term I’ve heard before visiting your blog. Could you (or someone else) explain it? I sort of think it may mean that while chalk may sometimes look like cheese, it’s not at all the same thing? Thanks.

    Comment by Cia Watson | September 30, 2008

  26. I was brought up in the Reorganized Church of Jesus Chist of Latter Day Saints,an offshoot of the Mormons, although we always argued with Mormons that we were right as we followed Joseph Smith and not Brigham Young, did not beleive the Adam god theory or accept plural wives. I was baptised in that church at age 12 and had hands laid on to receive the Holy Spirit (nothing happened) I remember feeling I was doing the right thing and continued on until I married, in that church and had 4 children. At a very low time in my life I began to search for truth, got really saved and filled with the Holy Spirit and spoke in tongues. I could not put the Bible down, it became a new book and the more I read the more the whole RLDS teaching was exposed. I compared the Book of Mormom and the Doctrine of Covenants against scripture and just could not believe that I had believed all that stuff was true. I also got baptised again as the Docttrine and Covenenants says we are baptised into that church by water baptism. RLDS teaching is that they are the only ones with the true gospel and that all other denominations are an “abomination to God” and the angel Moroni revealed the truth to Joseph Smith (sound familiar). Whilst I was in complete ignorance of the truth until an aunty continually encouraged and witnessed the truth to me, once I was saved it was impossible to try and blend the new with the old and I am sure if Roman Catholics or those from other denominations begin to search the Word of God they will be faced with the same choices as I did even in the face of family/friends opposition. However, it is easy to become complacent and just follow the new leaders and simply believe everything they say too, after all they were more mature christians with more knowledge and revelation!?. Over 35 years of being a Christian I have again been faced with those choices as I had failed to study the Word and test all things for myself! After watching the Lakeland fiasco I discovered again that the Word of God shines a very bright light on the works of darkness. Sadly many choose to follow blindly laying aside truth for excitment and false manifestations or traditions which are as blasphemous as any RC doctrine or practices. Please folks, don’t hang onto things just because you or your family have believed those things for years, if they don’t line up with the Word then they aren’t the truth. We in the free world can study the Word of God and fight for truth. Our freedoms have been won in the world and in the Church by faithful men and women who died defending the truth. Jesus said we can know the truth and the truth WILL set us free. He is the same yesterday, today and tomorrow

    Comment by Margie In Oz | September 30, 2008

  27. Cia

    Oh I am so sorry, I did not realise it was not an international expression. Here is an explanation from http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/chalk-and-cheese.html

    ‘Two things that are might possibly be confused but which are in fact very different.’

    The earliest citation of the phrase, in John Gower’s Confessio Amantis, 1390 does suggest some dodgy dealing, in which cheese is replaced with chalk:

    Lo, how they feignen chalk for chese.

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 30, 2008

  28. Karina –

    I think you are taling about the concept of ’soul sleep’ which is a very interesting topic. I know Jacob Prasch had a very long discussion with another ‘theologian’ Robert Morey on it. You might want to google for it as it contains lots of theology.

    Here is another link -
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soul_sleep

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 30, 2008

  29. Part of the testimony from Bill White: http://soulrefuge.wordpress.com/2007/07/27/my-testimony-from-darkness-to-light-2/

    “During the mid 1980’s Cathy and I became aware of the Catholic Charismatic movement. The Mass was livelier and the songs were similar to those sung in Christian churches. We attended “healing masses” which focused on healing and praying the rosary. The rosary contains prayers which are mostly “Hail Mary’s”. At that time we became aware of what was known as the Marian apparitions at Medugorje. The “Virgin Mary” was allegedly appearing before some young men and women and bringing forth a monthly message. We were fascinated by stories of rosary beads changing colors, from silver to gold, when people went to Medugorje.

    During this same period we began visiting a church in New York City where the gospel of Jesus Christ was being preached. We heard testimonies of how people’s lives were being changed by the power of Jesus Christ. This fascinated us also because we were so accustomed to the rituals and rote prayers we said every Sunday at the Catholic Mass. As time went on we would attend Mass in the morning and visit the other church in the evening, and the power of God’s Word was bringing us into the knowledge of the truth.

    Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed; And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free. (John 8:31-32)

    Cathy told a Christian woman at that other church about the alleged appearances over in Yugoslavia. The woman quoted a verse of scripture to her:

    And no marvel; for Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light. (2 Corinthians 11:14)

    This troubled Cathy and she went before the Lord and asked Him to show her the truth no matter what. She prayed before the Lord with an open Bible and an open heart, and began to see many scriptures which contradicted the messages that were coming from the “apparition of Mary” in Yugoslavia. This was very upsetting to her because we were really into this apparition thing. We had purchased videos and invited others to come to our home to view them with us. We also handed out pamphlets which promoted the apparition. We were evangelists for Mary at that time. Cathy was convinced that this whole thing was not of God and she tried to convince me, but I was not willing to listen. This went on for several weeks until one day she came down the stairs with tears in her eyes and asked me to listen to her. Something inside my heart told me to listen, and I did, and I told her that I would pray about it.

    knew that I had a choice to make. It was either the word of God (the bible) or the messages of “Mary” from Medugorje. I chose to believe the word of God. I can remember the day when the Lord lifted the spiritual veil of deception which had covered my eyes. I was reading the gospel of John and it seemed that the words were jumping off the page at me. I knew at that moment that the Lord Jesus Christ was the Son of God who came down from heaven. I knew that the Lord Jesus Christ was persecuted and slain on the cross for my sins. This was “head knowledge” before but now it was revelation truth from heaven straight into my heart. The Lord Jesus Christ had become ever so real to me and I knew that He died for me. A change had taken place inside my heart, and I was born again in the true biblical way. Jesus said this:

    That which is born of the flesh is flesh; and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit. Marvel not that I said unto thee, Ye must be born again. (John 3:6-7)

    Cathy and I researched the messages from Medugorje and it was as if the Holy Spirit had taken a fluorescent hi-liter pen and began to expose the contradictions and falsehoods within those messages. We did the same with the other apparitions of Mary and we found them to contain similar errors.

    As new Christians we now believed what Peter said and that we were now part of the “priesthood of believers” (1 Peter 2:9) which encompasses people from every nation on planet earth. We now knew that we did not need the Roman Catholic Mass, which is called the “Perfect Sacrifice Continued” (item 360 Baltimore Catechism p171), and which declares as its purpose “to satisfy the justice of God for the sins committed against Him” (Item 361 Baltimore Catechism p173). We now believed what Jesus Christ proclaimed right before His life expired “It Is Finished” (John 19:30). We now believed what Peter told us in one of his letters:

    For Christ also hath once suffered for sins, the just for the unjust, that he might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh, but quickened by the Spirit: (1 Peter 3:18)

    We now believed what the apostle Paul told us in his letter to the Romans. We saw the value of the blood of Jesus Christ like never before.

    But God commendeth his love toward us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. Much more then, being now justified by his blood, we shall be saved from wrath through him. (Romans 5:8-9)

    We now knew that the Mass, which declares that Christ through the ministry of the priest is offering Himself to God in “an unbloody manner” (item 357 Baltimore Catechism p168), was not in agreement with the Word of God which tells us this:

    For the life of the flesh is in the blood: and I have given it to you upon the altar to make an atonement for your souls: for it is the blood that maketh an atonement for the soul. (Leviticus 17:11)

    We also knew from studying the scriptures that the real Mary was a sinner just like the rest of us:

    And Mary said, My soul doth magnify the Lord, And my spirit hath rejoiced in God my Saviour. (Luke 1:46-47)

    Only sinners need a Saviour, and the Bible tells us that every single one of us has come short of the glory of God.

    For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God.(Romans 3:23)

    The last time that I find Mary mentioned in the scriptures is in the book of Acts:

    And when they were come in, they went up into an upper room, where abode both Peter, and James, and John, and Andrew, Philip, and Thomas, Bartholomew, and Matthew, James the son of Alphaeus, and Simon Zelotes, and Judas the brother of James. These all continued with one accord in prayer and supplication, with the women, and Mary the mother of Jesus, and with his brethren. (Acts 1:13-14)

    Mary is listed here along with everyone else and she most certainly is not exalted above the others who are mentioned here. Mary was praying along with the rest of the other believers in Jesus Christ unto her God. None of the others are found praying to her as I did for many years and is still done today by multitudes.

    One of the most striking things to me was the fact that the second commandment found in the Baltimore Catechism was not the same second commandment found in the bible. The real second commandment is found in Exodus 20 and reads as follows:

    Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me; And shewing mercy unto thousands of them that love me, and keep my commandments. (Exodus 20:4-6)

    In the Roman Catholic Baltimore Catechism the second commandment is listed as “Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain.” (Baltimore Catechism item number 195, p 100)

    How could there still be Ten commandments if the second commandment which dealt with graven images (statues) and which took up three verses in the scriptures is removed from the list?

    The answer is found by taking a look at the ninth and tenth commandments in the Baltimore Catechism which are as follows:

    9) Thou shalt not covet thy neighbors wife.

    10) Thou shalt not covet thy neighbors goods.

    (Baltimore Catechism item number 195, p100)

    But the bible relegates only one single verse to this subject which is found below.

    Thou shalt not covet thy neighbour’s house, thou shalt not covet thy neighbour’s wife, nor his manservant, nor his maidservant, nor his ox, nor his ass, nor any thing that is thy neighbour’s. (Exodus 20:17)

    The Lord really opened up my eyes with this one because statues are found in Roman Catholic Churches all over the world. There are shrines to Mary all over the world. There are statues built to honor “saints” all over the world. I can remember visiting a Catholic shop in search of a statue of Mary because I wanted to have my own little shrine in the attic of my home. A person had a choice of a plain white statue or one which included the colors of blue and white. I was shocked at the prices for even the smaller statues, and I never bought one. It was not long after that visit to the Catholic shop, that I got saved and saw all of these things as nothing but idolatry according to God’s word.

    As the Lord continued to open up my eyes about the deception of Roman Catholicism I would share this with others including pastors. I soon found out that this is an issue which most pastors refrain from speaking about. There was so much compromise I did not know where to begin. I have to remind myself that the bible warns us about such things in the following verse:

    Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils; (1 Timothy 4:1)

    If the Spirit of God, which is the Spirit of truth prophesied of such apostasy then it must certainly happen. Many pastors walk under the disguise of a “love” which is nothing but a counterfeit love which creates a false “unity” of believers in Jesus Christ. They lay aside the truth of God’s word and accept the doctrines of devils which Paul warned us about. On the surface they appear to be “anointed” but in reality they are crafty compromiser’s of God’s word. Some are very aware of what is going on, but they remain silent because it is not popular to speak out against these things. True love warns people about false doctrine and calls it what it is in order to protect the sheep. True Godly and biblical love can be found in the ministry of the Jewish apostle Paul who never failed to warn the people whom he loved so dearly.

    Wherefore I take you to record this day, that I am pure from the blood of all men. For I have not shunned to declare unto you all the counsel of God. Take heed therefore unto yourselves, and to all the flock, over the which the Holy Ghost hath made you overseers, to feed the church of God, which he hath purchased with his own blood. For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock. Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them. Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears. (Acts 20:26-31)”

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 30, 2008

  30. Miriam, your bigotry is showing. And it’s really, really sad.

    To claim that Catholics are not Christians betrays, at minimum, a near-absolute ignorance of history. I know about this myself, because, before I went to college, I’d been taught at church to believe in the apostolic age, then jump forward 1400 years to the Reformation, totally ignoring what went in between. You would not be a Christian today if it were not for the Catholic church.

    Now, this is not to say that the Catholic church doesn’t have some very serious problems. My significant other is Catholic, and whenever the Pope or the local bishop or some other bishop does something boneheadedly stupid, he gets an earful from me. He’s also very aware of the problems, and if he’s not, he asks me, because I’ll use my Google-Fu to find out. Example: he asked me, “what’s this stuff about Mary Co-Redemptrix? what’s that about?” I did some Google-Fu and found out that there’s a movement within the Catholic church to declare the “fifth Marian dogma,” that Mary was co-Redemptrix with Jesus. I told him it was my considered opinion that politically, this was never going to ever become an official dogma, because it would cause too many problems in trying to gather back all those separated churches.

    Of course, over the years, I’ve migrated my way out of Christendom, so my criticism of churchy-type stuff has become even more pointed and bitter. Yep. Still annoyed that I spent 30+ years of my life being afraid. Catholicism is the least of my problems, but you really need to look at that bigotry and ask if that reflects the Jesus you claim to worship.

    Comment by mirele | September 30, 2008

  31. Mirele:

    The definition of bigot is someone who ‘is strongly partial to one’s own group, religion, race, or politics and is intolerant of those who differ.’ This is not true of me. You and your partner can believe whatever you like, I will tolerate your freedom in that [but not accept it as truth and warn you of its eternal consequences]. I will allow you if you want to believe it that God is a green robot and lives in a flying saucer, BUT if you insist that your beliefs are ‘Christian’ and expect me to accept them as Christian, then of course I will vigorously refute that, because it just ain’t so. {And by the way isn’t it equally being bigoted by your logic for you to insist I must believe and declare as YOU do?}

    If we had no source text to refer to, and just my and your opinions, then I would be hard pushed to be able to say with any authority: ‘no, the Christian God is not a green robot living in a flying saucer’ – but we do, the Bible. And that source text shows clearly that God is not a green robot. Because of the source text I can be as bold as I am when declaring that Catholicism is fundamentally wrong at its core when claiming to be ‘Christian’ as I am in declaring the Christian God is not a green robot living in a flying saucer.

    Nobody would be being a bigot for insisting that William Shakespeare wrote about ‘Romeo and Juliet’ and not ‘Rolland and Julia’ for this facts would be based on facts and historical record. It would be sound scholarly work and exegesis, not just mere personal opinion. And so with my claim that the Roman Catholic faith and the true gospel are very, very different on many scores. It is not just my opinion. This FACT is based on the word of God. My source text is the Word of God which throws light on exactly what Catholicism is and is not. And I am NOT just talking about Catholic fringe beliefs or ‘heretical’ schisms but ‘essential’ Roman dogma.

    Just because Roman Catholics have claimed to be Christians and have claimed succession all the way back to Peter for hundreds of years means nothing apart from folk have swallowed this lie for hundreds of years. Anybody can call themselves anything or claim anything and it is not necessarily true. Peter was NOT the first pope. I know you are more intelligent than that, Mirele, surely.

    Your other half is free to believe what he wants. But if he thinks that Catholicim is Biblical ‘Christianity’ then he is deluded – as are you if you back him up.

    >>You would not be a Christian today if it were not for the Catholic church.

    I am a Christian today IN SPITE OF the Catholic church who did their best to keep me in darkness, never taught me or anyone else the gospel, opposed it rather at every stage, and when I converted attempted to pull me back into the fold. They continually persecute the truth. If the Catholic Church had not ever existed many more people would not be in hell and would be true Christians. Many martyr’s blood would not have been spilt. You talk about bigots – your other half is enjoined with the real bigots.

    You also have a poor version of church history. The RC church were not the only ‘church’ before the protestant reformation in the 16th century. We may not have heard of the TRUE church – the dissenters to Rome – in the dark ages because they were so persecuted, many scattered and many were slaughtered by Rome.

    But some names we do know. There were pre-reformers such as Wycliffe and Hus and Lollardy hundreds of years before the Reformation. There were also the Waldenses from around the 12th century. And notably the ‘Vaudois’ or ‘Valley Dwellers’ from very early on – around the 5th and 6th cntury http://www.giveshare.org/churchhistory/DuggerDodd/Dugger09.html

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 30, 2008

  32. Hi Mariam,

    My son goes to a Catholic School, because the Christian Charismatic church that he was going to before became heavily influenced with Lakeland. My thinking in puting him there was that although it was catholic it may be just a little more hands off, because they had so many children who were not catholic going there.

    From the beginning I told the Principal that my son is not to take communion or pray, but he would respect them if they did it. Her response was “Thats fine, but he should neil during prayer”. I immediatly felt uneasy about that, but being that we were in a hurried meeting I didnt get around to asking the most important question “neil to what”.
    But i did tell my son that not under any circumstances was he to bow or neil to a statue of Mary and we had discussed the toppic of the Catholic Church befor I made the decision to put him there.

    So that Friday my son came home saying that they had to neil to a statue of Jesus on the cross, I felt a little relieved because I was not really wanting to have to call the school if it was a statue of Mary and tell them that he could not do it(being that my son was already new and it was hard to find good schools), but I still feel like something is not pleasing to God about my son neiling and that I’m causing him to sin in some way.

    I know its wrong but I feel like I will be setting my son up for some mistreatment if I call and tell them that my son cant neil. But if I get confirmation that its definitly idolatric for him to neil to a statue that is not the true Jesus we believe in I will call in a heart beat. I just need proof for me.

    I was also wondering if you have any leassons that I can use in our home bible study to show my son and myself clearly why catholicism is wrong, because I have always considered it somewhat of a cult. I was taught that catholism was wrong from a young age, but I need to be armed with teaching that has facts and scripture that are A,B,C basic in style.

    Comment by Renee | September 30, 2008

  33. I mean that it was a Christian charasmatic School that he went to instead of church

    Comment by Renee | September 30, 2008

  34. Renee:

    Kneeling before any statue is wrong, even if it is of the ‘real’ Jesus {and the catholic Jesus and the real one are different anyway]. I would guess they also make him do a sign of the cross while doing so, which is also pagan based ritual?

    Also not making a graven image of anything is one of the ten commandments. It is wrong whatever he is doing.

    I do understand where you are coming from, wanting the best for your son’s education. Roman Catholic schools can be very good educationally, but….

    Comment by endtimespropheticwords | September 30, 2008

  35. Thanks,

    I guess I knew how blasphamous it was, but I was not sure if I was over reacting. So maney people (including my pastor) told me I was not causing him to sin, but I could not reconsile the neiling with the Word. I forbid him from doing the sign of the cross though.

    I called the Princilple and she isnt sure what to do, because she says they are not praying to the statue but to God, so she is going to have the Priest call. Im standing firm this time, but its hard. Being that Im a single mom.

    Keep me in prayer. Im deffinitly not going to back down!

    Comment by Renee | September 30, 2008

  36. A new look at Revelation. It has nothing to do with the Catholic Church or the Pope.

    Comment by lake | September 30, 2008

  37. Dear Miriam,

    thanks for clearing up the ‘chalk and cheese’ reference. :-)

    Comment by Cia Watson | October 1, 2008

  38. Miriam: I’m very well aware that there were other “churches” out there before the 16th century. For example, people tend to forget about the Eastern Orthodox churches. There were heretical movements as well, such as the Cathars and Bogomils. But one of the hallmarks of separtist Protestantism is this notion, unproven by history, of unconquered survivals from the 2nd century until the Reformation. In Western Europe, that is simply not the case. The Catholic church was very good in absorbing local practice and bringing it into the larger faith. Careful examination of the historical record doesn’t find these proto-Protestant survivals that your link claims existed.

    Protestantism requires something that the Dark and Middle ages did not have much of, and that is an educated populace and ready access to printed materials. One cannot teach absolute reliance upon the Bible as the sole deposit of faith if one cannot read and one does not have access to a Bible. It’s much easier to spread practices such as recitation of the Rosary, the Angelus and other prayers while a priest mutters a mass in Latin if the population is heavily illiterate, as was the case before access to mass printing methods.

    And where there were “alternative” faiths, such as the Cathars, it’s very clear that the authorities were quite willing to go very much out of their way to suppress such faiths, even if it meant killing thousands of people in one day (22 July 1209 in Beziers, Languedoc).

    So, I will disagree with you on the notion that there were proto-Protestant or post-Apostolic survivals.

    And, finally, I don’t claim to be a Christian.

    Comment by mirele | October 1, 2008

  39. ETPW, Re post #28:
    Ha Ha! While googling the debate you suggested between Morey and Prasch I found this.
    http://www.moriel.org/articles/discernment/church_issues/false_prophecies_elections.htm

    Comment by karina | October 1, 2008

  40. Renee . . .

    Re your comment “So many people (including my pastor) told me I was not causing him to sin” . . .

    Unfortunately this is the state of the organizational church. When I was first saved and a new believer the Lord showed both me and my husband to come out of Roman Catholicism. We witnessed to relatives and after a period of time some were saved (very few). One of the saved ones called her Christian church for counsel regarding what to do in a certain situation regarding attending a Catholic event. She was told by the person who answered the phone that they were also of a Catholic background and that they go to every Catholic function in their family. Not only that, but the person said that the Pastor also attended all Catholic functions. I was sick when my relative repeated the story to me. What does that tell you about the state of the church? I’m not saying pull your son out of the school, that is unless the Lord clearly tells you to do so, but I would stand firm and not cave in to the priest’s demands under any circumstances.

    My daughter was saved around the same time that my husband and I were saved. She was about 14 at the time. That was 20 years ago. My son then 13, was rebellious (still is, please pray). She was brought to meet with a Catholic priest in order to sway her back to Catholicism. She was not swayed. The priest said that she was in rebellion and that my son was in good standing with God. (A classic case of calling good evil and evil good.) My daughter attended a Catholic highschool after she was born again. (Her father had control of the school situation. I was divorced and already remarried 7 years when I was saved.) But while she was there she was never forced to do anything that went against her beliefs.

    The bottom line is keep close to the Lord in prayer and be rooted in the Word of God because we are living in days where many people will be going to hell directly from their pews. Forgive me if I sound dramatic but many times we cannot trust the counsel of “Christian” pastors or other Christians. I encourage you by telling you what I’m sure you already know . . . God is faithful.

    Cathy

    Comment by Cathy | October 1, 2008

  41. This isn’t directly related but I wanted to add my experience about statues. I work in a hospital where there is a very large statue of Christ in one of the buildings. At the bottom of the statue many people leave prayers for the Lord to heal their loved ones etc. At the time several years ago I was not testing things and was living in deception. I saw a man place his finger in the nail hole that was on the foot of the statue. So after he left I did the same thing. I prayed that the Lod would allow me to change my work schedule as it was oppressive to me. I was on call on weekends and could not catch up with housework and other responsibilities and I saw not way out.I was miserable and depressed.
    The next day my boss told me I didn’t have to work that schedule and took me off weekends which was highly unusual since there was no replacement to cover weekends.
    Frankly I don’t know if that was God answering my prayer despite myself or another jesus who saught to keep me beleiving in this religious witchcraft, but I am saddened that so many people are idolatrous and don’t understand what they are doing. I have since repented.

    Comment by Mary B | October 1, 2008

  42. Awwww, i am sorry u left Catholicism. You should have read the Early Church Fathers. :(

    Comment by Anthony Vu | February 9, 2009


Leave a comment